Colombian natilla is an iconic dessert that evokes cherished memories of Christmas celebrations in Colombia. This sweet treat, characterized by its creamy consistency and unique flavor, is prepared in every home, making each bite an experience steeped in tradition.
In this article, you will discover the most delicious and easy-to-make Colombian custard recipe , along with variations and tips so you can enjoy this delicacy at any time of the year.
How to make traditional Colombian custard
Traditional Colombian natilla is made with few ingredients, but it requires a little patience and love. This dessert is ideal for sharing with family during the holidays, especially at Christmas.
To begin, it is important that you prepare all the necessary ingredients and utensils before starting cooking.
The key to making custard is to cook it over low heat, to prevent it from sticking or burning. Remember that a creamy texture is essential for your custard to be a success.
Use a whisk to mix the ingredients evenly, making sure there are no lumps. Now on to the recipe!
Ingredients to prepare Colombian custard
Below are the basic ingredients you will need to make a delicious Colombian custard :
- 1 liter of milk
- 200 grams of sugars
- 1 cup cornstarch
- 1 cinnamon stick
- 1 teaspoon vanilla essence
- A pinch of salt
These are the basic ingredients, but you can add others like shredded coconut or panela to give your custard a different touch.
Remember that the quality of the milk is essential to achieve a creamy and delicious dessert. Choose whole milk for best results.
Most selled products
Venezuelan Guasacaca Sauce, Green Sauce, 8 OZ – Salsas Mosaico
The original price was: $21.00.$16.96The current price is: $16.96.Frozen Venezuelan Tequeños, Latin Cheese Fingers (28 units)
The original price was: $62.00.$44.50The current price is: $44.50.Garlic Sauce, 8 OZ – Mosaic Sauces
The original price was: $21.00.$16.96The current price is: $16.96.Frozen Mini Venezuelan Chicken Empanadas (2 Bags of 12 Units)
The original price was: $56.00.$45.90The current price is: $45.90.Frozen Mini Venezuelan Ground Beef Empanadas (2 Bags of 12 Units)
The original price was: $56.00.$45.90The current price is: $45.90.
What is the difference between Colombian and Venezuelan custard?
Colombian and Venezuelan natilla are very similar; however, there are some differences that make them unique. Colombian natilla is usually thicker and is prepared with milk and cornstarch, while Venezuelan natilla tends to be thinner and sometimes includes condensed milk.
In addition, in Colombia, cinnamon and vanilla are often added, giving it a more aromatic flavor, while in Venezuela they may use evaporated milk and, on some occasions, incorporate spices such as anise.
Another aspect that differentiates them is the presentation. In Colombia, natilla is usually cut into squares and served cold, while in Venezuela, it can be served in larger portions and is often accompanied by other desserts.
Colombian custard recipe with condensed milk
If you'd like to give your Colombian custard recipe a twist , you can try the version with condensed milk. This ingredient adds a unique sweetness and unparalleled creaminess.
For this recipe, in addition to the above ingredients, you will need:
- 1 can of condensed milk
- 2 cups of milk
The process is very similar to the traditional recipe. Just make sure to thoroughly dissolve the condensed milk with the milk before adding the cornstarch. This step ensures that the mixture is homogeneous and delicious.
How to make custard with cornstarch?
Custard made with cornstarch is one of the most common ways to prepare this dessert. The cornstarch acts as a thickener, allowing the custard to reach the desired consistency.
To make it, simply mix the cornstarch with a little cold milk before adding it to the hot mixture. This prevents lumps from forming and ensures that your custard has a smooth texture.
When cooking, it is essential to keep stirring the mixture to achieve a uniform thickness. Don't forget to taste the mixture and adjust the sugar level to your liking!
Colombian custard: tips for a perfect result
Now that you know several recipes, here are some tips to make sure your custard turns out perfect every time:
- Stir constantly: This prevents it from sticking to the bottom of the pot.
- Use medium heat: Very high heat can burn the custard.
- Allow to cool properly: This will allow the custard to take on the correct texture.
- Decorate with cinnamon: Sprinkle a little cinnamon powder before serving for a special touch.
These small details can make a big difference in the final result of your custard.
How to prepare boxed custard?
Boxed custard is a quick and easy option for those looking for something convenient. You just need to follow the instructions on the package, which usually include mixing the contents with milk and heating over medium heat.
Make sure to whisk constantly to avoid lumps. You can also customize it by adding ingredients like shredded coconut , nuts, or dried fruit.
Although boxed custard may not taste the same as homemade custard, it is a great alternative for those short on time.
How to make traditional custard
Easy and delicious Colombian custard recipe
Golden tacos: easy and delicious recipe
Pastelitos Guava and cheese pastries
Mexican Sopes: Complete Preparation and Fillings Guide | 2025
Related questions about the Colombian custard recipe
What's in custard?
Custard is a dessert that generally contains basic ingredients such as milk, sugar, and a thickener like cornstarch. It may also include spices like cinnamon and vanilla, which add flavor. Some recipes also incorporate additional ingredients such as shredded coconut or fruit.
What do I do if the custard doesn't thicken?
If your custard doesn't thicken, it may be that you haven't cooked it for long enough or that the proportion of cornstarch wasn't correct. In this case, you can reheat the mixture and add a little more cornstarch dissolved in cold milk, making sure to whisk well to avoid lumps.
How healthy is custard?
Custard can be a fairly high-calorie dessert due to the amount of sugar and milk. However, as it is a traditional sweet treat, it can be enjoyed from time to time as part of a balanced diet. If you are looking for healthier options, consider using skim milk and cutting back on sugar.
New Arrivals
Frozen Mini Venezuelan Chicharrón Arepas (2 Bags of 14 Units)
The original price was: $45.00.$43.15The current price is: $43.15.Frozen Venezuelan tequeños, Latin cheese fingers (box 56 units)
The original price was: $115.00.$76.25The current price is: $76.25.Frozen Mini Venezuelan Dogfish Empanadas (2 Bags of 12 Units)
The original price was: $56.00.$45.90The current price is: $45.90.Frozen Mini Venezuelan Dogfish Empanadas (Box of 48 Units)
The original price was: $95.00.$78.25The current price is: $78.25.Frozen Mini Venezuelan Chicken Empanadas (2 Bags of 12 Units)
The original price was: $56.00.$45.90The current price is: $45.90.
How long does a custard last in the fridge?
A well-prepared custard can last between 3 and 5 days in the refrigerator. It is important to cover it properly to prevent it from absorbing odors from other foods. To enjoy it at its best, it is recommended to consume it within the first few days after making it.
When gathering ingredients to make Colombian natilla , it's essential to have milk, sugar, cornstarch, cinnamon, and vanilla extract. This combination of elements creates a traditional dessert that evokes the warmth of family celebrations. Each ingredient contributes a characteristic flavor and consistency that make homemade Colombian natilla an unforgettable culinary experience.
Colombian natilla is a culinary treasure, passed down through generations. Its preparation, though simple, requires careful attention during the cooking process, as the precise thickness is what defines it. Patience and care are also secret ingredients that every cook must add to achieve that distinctive creamy texture.
For those who love traditional sweets, Colombian natilla is a must-have on the table during the holidays. Although simple to make, the result is a dessert that captivates with its flavor and, served chilled and sprinkled with cinnamon, becomes a delight for young and old alike. Natilla is undoubtedly an emblem of Colombian confectionery.
